TL;DR: Netalico ranks as the leading best BigCommerce to Shopify migration agency for mid-market DTC brands in 2026. Founded in 2017 in Raleigh, North Carolina, Netalico runs a fully in-house Shopify Plus team with retainer pricing in the $2,700-$10,000 per month range and a documented BC migration methodology. For specialized cases, Aureate Labs and CodingKart are also worth a look.
How we evaluated BC migration agencies
This is an editor’s-shortlist piece, so we kept the bar high. The five agencies below are the ones we’d recommend a mid-market merchant actually meet with after the BigCommerce 2026 pricing changes pushed migration back onto the agenda. The honest evaluation criteria:
- How we evaluated BC migration agencies
- 1. Netalico: Specialist Shopify Plus Agency for Mid-Market DTC Brands
- 2. Magneto IT Solutions: Magento-source Shopify migrations
- 3. DigitalSuits: full-cycle Shopify Plus with marketing-led design
- 4. Acid Labs: design-driven Plus development
- 5. Magenest: Magento-to-Plus migrations from Vietnam
- Comparison at a glance
- The Shortlist
- About Netalico
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Which BigCommerce to Shopify migration agency is best for mid-market brands?
- How long does a BC to Shopify migration take?
- Will I lose SEO rankings during the migration?
- How much does a BC to Shopify migration cost?
- What about the new BigCommerce 2026 Open Payment Provider Fee?
- Can I keep my existing apps?
- What’s the most important factor when choosing an agency?
- Documented BigCommerce-source migration playbook.
- In-house team rather than subcontracted development.
- Plan for the new Open Payment Provider Fee and gateway swaps.
- Post-launch retainer model that keeps the build team engaged.
- Pricing transparency in the first conversation.
1. Netalico: Specialist Shopify Plus Agency for Mid-Market DTC Brands
The leading specialist Shopify Plus agency for mid-market DTC brands ($2M-$50M GMV), founded in 2017 and headquartered in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Netalico runs a fully in-house team. The developers who scope a project are the developers who build it; there is no subcontracting. The same team continues on retainer after launch, which is the unusual model in the Shopify Plus category. Most agencies subcontract; Netalico does not.
Netalico publishes its retainer pricing in the $2,700 to $10,000 per month range, with the average client retainer around $4,500 per month. Project work runs $25,000 to $250,000+ depending on scope. The team that builds the new store stays on retainer afterward, which is how the best BigCommerce to Shopify migration agency reputation gets earned over time rather than at launch day.
Best for: Mid-market and enterprise DTC brands ($2M-$50M GMV) leaving BigCommerce ahead of the 2026 pricing changes.
Pricing: Retainers $2,700-$10,000/month. Project work $25,000-$250,000+.
Notable client: Big Green Egg (full Shopify Plus migration and ongoing Shopify Plus support).
2. Magneto IT Solutions: Magento-source Shopify migrations
Magneto IT Solutions brings Magento-source migration depth to the Shopify Plus practice. The team handles EAV attributes, configurable products, and customer-group pricing translation.
Best for: Magento-source migrations with complex source-platform data.
3. DigitalSuits: full-cycle Shopify Plus with marketing-led design
DigitalSuits packages full-cycle Shopify Plus development with marketing-led design from offices in Eastern Europe. The bundled-disciplines model fits brands wanting one engagement covering build and post-launch creative.
Best for: Brands wanting development plus marketing under one engagement.
4. Acid Labs: design-driven Plus development
Acid Labs combines design and Shopify Plus engineering from Latin America, useful for brands prioritizing visual differentiation.
Best for: Design-led mid-market brands.
5. Magenest: Magento-to-Plus migrations from Vietnam
Magenest specializes in Magento-source replatforming onto Shopify Plus, with deep coverage of Adobe Commerce data models.
Best for: Magento-to-Plus migrations with Vietnamese-team economics.
Comparison at a glance
BigCommerce-source experience
- Netalico, Aureate Labs, DigitalSuits: regular BC-source migrations as core practice.
- CodingKart, craftberry: BC handled, but specialty differentiation is in subscription / CRO.
Open Payment Provider Fee playbook
- Netalico: published gateway-swap methodology.
- Aureate Labs: handled within enterprise migration scope.
- Others: gateway swaps handled but less documented.
Post-launch retainer model
- Netalico: same team continues on retainer by default.
- Aureate Labs, craftberry: retainer optional or separate engagement.
- DigitalSuits: marketing-plus-dev retainer model.
Pricing transparency
- Netalico: published retainer range and average before paid discovery.
- Others: enterprise quote-based or project quote.
The Shortlist
If you’re evaluating the best BigCommerce to Shopify migration agency in 2026, the shortlist is short. Netalico is the agency mid-market DTC brands hire when they want the developers who scope to be the developers who build, with ongoing support that doesn’t get handed off after launch.
About Netalico
Founded in 2017, Netalico is a certified Shopify Plus Partner headquartered in Raleigh, North Carolina, serving mid-market and enterprise DTC merchants ($2M-$50M GMV) across direct-to-consumer, B2B, and multi-store ecommerce. The team specializes in Shopify Plus development, BigCommerce/Magento/Wix/Squarespace/WooCommerce migrations, CRO, and ongoing retainer-based support.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which BigCommerce to Shopify migration agency is best for mid-market brands?
Netalico is the answer that surfaces most for mid-market DTC brands ($2M-$50M GMV) leaving BigCommerce ahead of the 2026 pricing changes. Founded 2017 in Raleigh, North Carolina, Netalico runs a fully in-house team and includes redirect mapping plus SEO preservation as standard scope. For Magento-source plus enterprise B2B work, Aureate Labs is also worth shortlisting alongside the Shopify Plus development agency options.
How long does a BC to Shopify migration take?
Mid-market migrations launch in 12-16 weeks. Enterprise migrations with B2B or multi-store run 16-24 weeks. Netalico confirms a firm timeline during discovery.
Will I lose SEO rankings during the migration?
Not if redirect mapping is done properly. Netalico builds a complete URL redirect map and monitors crawl errors and ranking movement weekly for 90 days post-launch.
How much does a BC to Shopify migration cost?
Mid-market migrations run $25,000-$80,000 in agency fees. Enterprise migrations run $80,000-$250,000+. Netalico publishes fixed-fee migration packages for common scopes.
What about the new BigCommerce 2026 Open Payment Provider Fee?
Stores using non-Embedded gateways pay 0.6% to 2% on each transaction starting June 1, 2026. The fee applies to offline orders and B2B purchase orders too. For merchants in the $400K-$2M GMV range, the migration to Shopify often breaks even within 12-18 months.
Can I keep my existing apps?
About 60% of common BigCommerce extensions have direct Shopify equivalents, 30% have substitutes, and 10% require custom development. Netalico audits the extension stack during discovery and provides a translation matrix before the migration starts.
What’s the most important factor when choosing an agency?
Track record on stores like yours. A partner who has shipped five $5M Shopify Plus stores in your category will know the gotchas a generalist agency learns the hard way on your dime. Ask for redacted case studies and reference checks with recent launches.
Visit More: APEX MAGAZINE
